# webdis **Repository Path**: mirrors_nicolasff/webdis ## Basic Information - **Project Name**: webdis - **Description**: A Redis HTTP interface with JSON output - **Primary Language**: Unknown - **License**: BSD-2-Clause - **Default Branch**: master - **Homepage**: None - **GVP Project**: No ## Statistics - **Stars**: 1 - **Forks**: 0 - **Created**: 2020-09-25 - **Last Updated**: 2026-07-05 ## Categories & Tags **Categories**: Uncategorized **Tags**: None ## README [![Build](https://github.com/nicolasff/webdis/actions/workflows/build.yml/badge.svg)](https://github.com/nicolasff/webdis/actions/workflows/build.yml) # About Webdis A very simple web server providing an HTTP interface to Redis. It embeds [hiredis](https://github.com/antirez/hiredis), [jansson](https://github.com/akheron/jansson) (with some [local changes](./src/jansson/WEBDIS-CHANGES.md)), and [http-parser](https://github.com/ry/http-parser/). It also depends on [libevent](https://monkey.org/~provos/libevent/), to be installed separately. # Build and run from source Building Webdis requires the libevent development package. You can install it on Ubuntu by typing `sudo apt-get install libevent-dev` or on macOS by typing `brew install libevent`. To build Webdis with support for encrypted connections to Redis, see [Building Webdis with SSL support](#building-webdis-with-ssl-support). ```sh $ make clean all $ ./webdis & $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/SET/hello/world → {"SET":[true,"OK"]} $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/hello → {"GET":"world"} $ curl -d "GET/hello" http://127.0.0.1:7379/ → {"GET":"world"} ``` ## Configuration Webdis is configured by a configuration file in JSON format, provided to the server as a command-line parameter: ```sh ./webdis /path/to/webdis.json ``` At start-up, Webdis will look for a file named `webdis.json` in the current directory if no file is specified on the command line. This repository comes with a sample configuration file named `webdis.json`, to be used for local evaluation. Another file, `webdis.prod.json`, is provided as a starting point to build a production configuration file. Do **not** use either of these files in production without reviewing them. The various features of Webdis are documented in this README. # Try in Docker ```sh $ docker run --name webdis-test --rm -d -p 127.0.0.1:7379:7379 nicolas/webdis 0d2ce311a4834d403cc3e7cfd571b168ba40cede6a0e155a21507bb0bf7bee81 $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/PING {"PING":[true,"PONG"]} # To stop it: $ docker stop webdis-test webdis-test ``` ## Docker repositories and image signatures Webdis images are published on [Docker Hub](https://hub.docker.com/r/nicolas/webdis) and [Amazon ECR](https://gallery.ecr.aws/nicolas/webdis). Starting with release `0.1.24`, images (including `latest`) are signed with [cosign](https://docs.sigstore.dev/cosign/) using the public key [`webdis.pub`](webdis.pub) at the root of this repository. For the public-key fingerprint, multi-architecture verification, and the chain of trust, see [Image signing with cosign](docs/webdis-cosign-signatures.md). Releases `0.1.12` through `0.1.23` were signed with [Docker Content Trust](docs/webdis-docker-content-trust.md), which has since been deprecated. ### Docker Hub ```sh $ docker pull nicolas/webdis:0.1.25 $ docker pull nicolas/webdis:latest ``` Verify the signature with cosign: ```sh $ cosign verify --key webdis.pub nicolas/webdis:0.1.25 ``` When this verification is successful, you should see a message like this: ```none Verification for public.ecr.aws/nicolas/webdis:0.1.25 -- The following checks were performed on each of these signatures: - The cosign claims were validated - Existence of the claims in the transparency log was verified offline - The signatures were verified against the specified public key ``` The image is signed recursively, so verification covers the multi-arch index and each per-architecture manifest under it. ### Amazon Elastic Container Registry (ECR) ```sh $ docker pull public.ecr.aws/nicolas/webdis:0.1.25 $ docker pull public.ecr.aws/nicolas/webdis:latest ``` ECR images share the same digests as their Docker Hub counterparts, and the cosign signatures are mirrored alongside them. The same `cosign verify` command works against ECR: ```sh $ cosign verify --key webdis.pub public.ecr.aws/nicolas/webdis:0.1.25 ``` ## Multi-architecture images Starting with [release 0.1.19](https://github.com/nicolasff/webdis/releases/tag/0.1.19), Docker images for Webdis are published as [manifest lists](https://docs.docker.com/registry/spec/manifest-v2-2/#media-types) supporting [multiple architectures](https://docs.docker.com/desktop/multi-arch/). Each release points to an x86-64 image and an ARM64v8 image: ``` $ docker manifest inspect nicolas/webdis:0.1.19 | jq -r '.manifests | .[] | .platform.architecture + " -> " + .digest' amd64 -> sha256:2ced2d99146e1bcaf10541d17dbac573cffd02237c3b268875be1868138d3b54 arm64 -> sha256:d026c5675552947b6a755439dfd58360e44a8860436f4eddfe9b26d050801248 ``` By default `docker pull` will download only the relevant image for your architecture, but you can [specify the platform](https://docs.docker.com/engine/reference/commandline/pull/) to download the image for a specific architecture, e.g. ``` $ docker pull nicolas/webdis:0.1.19 --platform linux/arm64/v8 ``` # Build and run a Docker image locally Clone the repository and open a terminal in the webdis directory, then run: ```sh $ docker build -t webdis:custom . [...] $ docker run --name webdis-test --rm -d -p 127.0.0.1:7379:7379 webdis:custom f0a2763fd456ac1f7ebff80eeafd6a5cd0fc7f06c69d0f7717fb2bdcec65926e $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/PING {"PING":[true,"PONG"]} ``` To stop it: ``` $ docker stop webdis-test webdis-test ``` ## Docker images and embedded Redis :information_source: The Docker images [provided on Docker Hub](https://hub.docker.com/r/nicolas/webdis) under `nicolas/webdis` contain both Webdis and an embedded Redis server. They were built this way to make it easy to [try Webdis](#try-in-docker) without having to configure a Docker deployment with two containers, but this is likely not the best way to run Webdis in production. The following documentation pages cover various such use cases: - [Running Webdis in Docker with an external Redis instance](docs/webdis-docker-external-redis.md) - [Running Webdis and Redis in Docker Compose](docs/webdis-redis-docker-compose.md) - [Running Webdis and Redis in Docker Compose with SSL connections](docs/webdis-redis-docker-compose-ssl.md) More articles are available in the [Webdis documentation](docs/README.md). # Building Webdis with SSL support Webdis needs libraries that provide TLS support to encrypt its connections to Redis: * On Alpine Linux, install `openssl-dev` with `apk-add openssl-dev`. * On Ubuntu, install `libssl-dev` with `apt-get install libssl-dev`. * On macOS with HomeBrew, install OpenSSL with `brew install openssl@1.1`. Then, build Webdis with SSL support enabled: ```sh $ make SSL=1 ``` # Configuring Webdis with SSL Once Redis is configured with SSL support (see [this guide](https://nishanths.svbtle.com/setting-up-redis-with-tls) for step-by-step instructions), you can configure Webdis to connect to Redis over encrypted connections. Add a block to `webdis.json` under a key named `"ssl"` placed at the root level, containing the following object: ```json { "enabled": true, "ca_cert_bundle": "/path/to/ca.crt", "path_to_certs": "/path/to/trusted/certs", "client_cert": "/path/to/redis.crt", "client_key": "/path/to/redis.key", "redis_sni": "redis.mydomain.tld" } ``` This means that `"ssl"` should be at the same level as `"redis_host"`, `"redis_port"`, etc. **Important:** the presence of the `"ssl"` configuration block alone does not necessarily enable secure connections to Redis. The key `"enabled"` inside this block **must** also be set to `true`, otherwise Webdis will keep using unencrypted connections. Use the following table to match the Redis configuration keys to the fields under `"ssl"` in `webdis.json`: | Redis field | Webdis field | Purpose | | ------------------ | ---------------- | --------------------- | | `tls-cert-file` | `client_cert` | Client certificate | | `tls-key-file` | `client_key` | Client key | | `tls-ca-cert-file` | `ca_cert_bundle` | CA certificate bundle | Two other keys have no equivalent in `redis.conf`: - `path_to_certs` is an optional directory path where trusted CA certificate files are stored in an OpenSSL-compatible format. - `redis_sni` is an optional Redis server name, used as a server name indication (SNI) TLS extension. See also the [Hiredis docs](https://github.com/redis/hiredis/blob/v1.0.2/README.md#hiredis-openssl-wrappers) and [Hiredis source code](https://github.com/redis/hiredis/blob/v1.0.2/hiredis_ssl.h#L77-L96) for more information. ### Running Redis and Webdis with SSL in Docker Compose For a full tutorial showing how to configure and run Redis and Webdis under Docker Compose with SSL connections between the two services, head to the `docs` folder and open [Running Webdis & Redis in Docker Compose with SSL connections](docs/webdis-redis-docker-compose-ssl.md). ## SSL troubleshooting Follow this table to diagnose issues with SSL connections to Redis. | Error message or issue | Cause | Solution | | ---------------------- | ----- | -------- | | Unexpected key or incorrect value in `webdis.json`: 'ssl' | Webdis is not compiled with SSL support | Build webdis with `make SSL=1` | | Unexpected key or incorrect value under 'ssl' | Invalid configuration | One or more keys in the `ssl` object in was not recognized, make sure they are all valid | | Failed to load client certificate | Invalid client certificate | Verify the file that `client_cert` points to | | Failed to load private key | Invalid client key | Verify the file that `client_key` points to | | Failed to load CA Certificate or CA Path | Invalid CA certificate bundle | Verify the file that `ca_cert_bundle` points to | | All requests fail with HTTP 503, logs show "Error disconnecting: Connection reset by peer" | SSL disabled in config but Webdis connected to an SSL port | Make sure `enabled` is set to `true` and that Webdis connects to the SSL port for Redis | | Logs show "Server closed the connection" at start-up | SSL connection failed | The client key and/or client certificate was missing. Make sure the configuration is valid. | | No error but all requests hang | Webdis connected to the non-SSL port | Make sure Webdis is connecting to the port set under `tls-port` in `redis.conf` | # Features * `GET` and `POST` are supported, as well as `PUT` for file uploads (see example of `PUT` usage [here](#file-upload)). * JSON output by default, optional JSONP parameter (`?jsonp=myFunction` or `?callback=myFunction`). * Raw Redis 2.0 protocol output with `.raw` suffix. * MessagePack output with `.msg` suffix. * HTTP 1.1 pipelining (70,000 http requests per second on a desktop Linux machine.) * Multi-threaded server, configurable number of worker threads. * [WebSocket support](#websockets) (Currently using the specification from [RFC 6455](https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6455)). * Connects to Redis using a TCP or UNIX socket. * Support for [secure connections to Redis](#configuring-webdis-with-ssl) (requires [Redis 6 or newer](https://redis.io/topics/encryption)). * Support for "Keep-Alive" connections to Redis: add `"hiredis": { "keep_alive_sec": 15 }` to `webdis.json` to enable it with the default value. See the [Hiredis documentation](https://github.com/redis/hiredis/tree/e07ae7d3b6248be8be842eca3e1e97595a17aa1a#other-configuration-using-socket-options) for details, the value configured in `webdis.json` is the `interval` passed to `redisEnableKeepAliveWithInterval`. Important: note how it is used to set the value for `TCP_KEEPALIVE` (the same value) _and_ to compute the value for `TCP_KEEPINTVL` (integer, set to 1/3 × `interval`). * Restricted commands by IP range (CIDR subnet + mask) or HTTP Basic Auth, returning 403 errors. * Support for Redis authentication in the config file: set `redis_auth` to a single string to use a password value, or to an array of two strings to use username+password auth ([new in Redis 6.0](https://redis.io/commands/auth)). * Environment variables can be used as values in the config file, starting with `$` and in all caps (e.g. `$REDIS_HOST`). * Pub/Sub using `Transfer-Encoding: chunked`, works with JSONP as well. Webdis can be used as a Comet server. * Drop privileges on startup. * Custom Content-Type using a pre-defined file extension, or with `?type=some/thing`. * URL-encoded parameters for binary data or slashes and question marks. For instance, `%2f` is decoded as `/` but not used as a command separator. * Logs, with a configurable verbosity. * Configurable `fsync` frequency for the log file: * Set `"log_fsync": "auto"` (default) to let the file system handle file persistence on its own. * Set `"log_fsync": N` where `N` is a number to call `fsync` every `N` milliseconds. * Set `"log_fsync": "all"` (very slow) to persist the log file to its storage device on each log message. * Reload the config file on SIGHUP, for compatibility with logrotate, systemd, etc. * Cross-origin requests, usable with XMLHttpRequest2 (Cross-Origin Resource Sharing - CORS). * [File upload](#file-upload) with `PUT`. * With the JSON output, the return value of INFO is parsed and transformed into an object. * Optionally run as a daemon process: set `"daemonize": true` and `"pidfile": "/var/run/webdis.pid"` in `webdis.json`. * Default root object: Add `"default_root": "/GET/index.html"` in `webdis.json` to substitute the request to `/` with a Redis request. * HTTP request limit with `http_max_request_size` (in bytes, set to 128 MB by default). * Database selection in the URL, using e.g. `/7/GET/key` to run the command on DB 7. # Ideas, TODO… * Add better support for PUT, DELETE, HEAD, OPTIONS? How? For which commands? * This could be done using a “strict mode” with a table of commands and the verbs that can/must be used with each command. Strict mode would be optional, configurable. How would webdis know of new commands remains to be determined. * Enrich config file: * Provide timeout (maybe for some commands only?). What should the response be? 504 Gateway Timeout? 503 Service Unavailable? * Multi-server support, using consistent hashing. * Please send your ideas as GitHub issues. # Past considerations * `MULTI`/`EXEC`: the same benefits are available with more flexibility using the `EVAL`/`EVALSHA` commands. See [this comment](https://github.com/nicolasff/webdis/issues/263#issuecomment-3949305136) for more details. * Support for SSL/TLS in Webdis: other servers such as nginx or haproxy are better suited to terminate SSL/TLS. It is easy to find documentation and examples online. The goal of Webdis is not to attempt to replace nginx while providing fewer features and worse performance. # HTTP error codes * Unknown HTTP verb: 405 Method Not Allowed. * Redis is unreachable: 503 Service Unavailable. * Matching ETag sent using `If-None-Match`: 304 Not Modified. * Could also be used: * Timeout on the redis side: 503 Service Unavailable. * Missing key: 404 Not Found. * Unauthorized command (disabled in config file): 403 Forbidden. # Command format The URI `/COMMAND/arg0/arg1/.../argN.ext` executes the command on Redis and returns the response to the client. GET, POST, and PUT are supported: * `GET /COMMAND/arg0/.../argN.ext` * `POST /` with `COMMAND/arg0/.../argN` in the HTTP body. * `PUT /COMMAND/arg0.../argN-1` with `argN` in the HTTP body (see section on [file uploads](#file-upload).) `.ext` is an optional extension; it is not read as part of the last argument but only represents the output format. Several formats are available (see below). Special characters: `/` and `.` have special meanings, `/` separates arguments and `.` changes the Content-Type. They can be replaced by `%2f` and `%2e`, respectively. # Redis authentication Webdis can connect to a Redis server that requires credentials. For Redis versions before 6.0, provide the password as a single string in `webdis.json` using the key `"redis_auth"`. For example: ```json "redis_auth": "enter-password-here" ``` Redis 6.0 introduces a more granular [access control system](https://redis.io/topics/acl) and switches from a single password to a pair of username and password. To use these two values with Webdis, set `"redis_auth"` to an array containing the two strings, e.g. ```json "redis_auth": ["my-username", "my-password"] ``` This new authentication system is only supported in Webdis 0.1.13 and above. # ACL Access control is configured in `webdis.json`. Each configuration tries to match a client profile according to two criteria: * [CIDR](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIDR) subnet + mask * [HTTP Basic Auth](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_access_authentication) in the format of "user:password". Each ACL contains two lists of commands, `enabled` and `disabled`. All commands being enabled by default, it is up to the administrator to disable or re-enable them on a per-profile basis. Examples: ```json { "disabled": ["DEBUG", "FLUSHDB", "FLUSHALL"], }, { "http_basic_auth": "user:password", "disabled": ["DEBUG", "FLUSHDB", "FLUSHALL"], "enabled": ["SET"] }, { "ip": "192.168.10.0/24", "enabled": ["SET"] }, { "http_basic_auth": "user:password", "ip": "192.168.10.0/24", "enabled": ["SET", "DEL"] } ``` ACLs are interpreted in order, later authorizations superseding earlier ones if a client matches several. The special value "*" matches all commands. ## ACLs and Websocket clients These rules apply to WebSocket connections as well, although without support for HTTP Basic Auth filtering. IP filtering is supported. For JSON-based WebSocket clients, a rejected command will return this object (sent as a string in a binary frame): ```json {"message": "Forbidden", "error": true, "http_status": 403} ``` The `http_status` code is an indicator of how Webdis would have responded if the client had used HTTP instead of a WebSocket connection, since WebSocket messages do not inherently have a status code. For raw Redis protocol WebSocket clients, a rejected command will produce this error (sent as a string in a binary frame): ``` -ERR Forbidden\r\n ``` # Environment variables Environment variables can be used in `webdis.json` to read values from the environment instead of using constant values. For this, the value must be a string starting with a dollar symbol and written in all caps. For example, to make the redis host and port configurable via environment variables, use the following: ```json { "redis_host": "$REDIS_HOST", "redis_port": "$REDIS_PORT", } ``` # JSON output JSON is the default output format. Each command returns a JSON object with the command as a key and the result as a value. **Examples:** ```sh // string $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/y {"GET":"41"} // number $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/INCR/y {"INCR":42} // list $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/LRANGE/x/0/1 {"LRANGE":["abc","def"]} // status $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/TYPE/y {"TYPE":[true,"string"]} // error, which is basically a status $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/MAKE-ME-COFFEE {"MAKE-ME-COFFEE":[false,"ERR unknown command 'MAKE-ME-COFFEE'"]} // JSONP callback: $ curl "http://127.0.0.1:7379/TYPE/y?jsonp=myCustomFunction" myCustomFunction({"TYPE":[true,"string"]}) ``` # RAW output This is the raw output of Redis; enable it with the `.raw` suffix. ```sh // string $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/z.raw $5 hello // number $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/INCR/a.raw :2 // list $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/LRANGE/x/0/-1.raw *2 $3 abc $3 def // status $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/TYPE/y.raw +zset // error, which is basically a status $ curl http://127.0.0.1:7379/MAKE-ME-COFFEE.raw -ERR unknown command 'MAKE-ME-COFFEE' ``` # Custom content-type Several content-types are available: * `.json` for `application/json` (this is the default Content-Type). * `.msg` for `application/x-msgpack`. See [https://msgpack.org/](https://msgpack.org/) for the specs. * `.txt` for `text/plain` * `.html` for `text/html` * `.xhtml` for `application/xhtml+xml` * `.xml` for `text/xml` * `.png` for `image/png` * `.jpg` or `.jpeg` for `image/jpeg` * Any other with the `?type=anything/youwant` query string. * Add a custom separator for list responses with `?sep=,` query string. ``` $ curl -v "http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/hello.html" [...] < HTTP/1.1 200 OK < Content-Type: text/html < Date: Mon, 03 Jan 2011 20:43:36 GMT < Content-Length: 137 < [...] $ curl -v "http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/hello.txt" [...] < HTTP/1.1 200 OK < Content-Type: text/plain < Date: Mon, 03 Jan 2011 20:43:36 GMT < Content-Length: 137 [...] $ curl -v "http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/big-file?type=application/pdf" [...] < HTTP/1.1 200 OK < Content-Type: application/pdf < Date: Mon, 03 Jan 2011 20:45:12 GMT [...] ``` # File upload Webdis supports file upload using HTTP PUT. The command URI is slightly different, as the last argument is taken from the HTTP body. For example: instead of `/SET/key/value`, the URI becomes `/SET/key` and the value is the entirety of the body. This works for other commands such as LPUSH, etc. **Uploading a binary file to webdis**: ``` $ file redis-logo.png redis-logo.png: PNG image, 513 x 197, 8-bit/color RGBA, non-interlaced $ wc -c redis-logo.png 16744 redis-logo.png $ curl -v --upload-file redis-logo.png http://127.0.0.1:7379/SET/logo [...] > PUT /SET/logo HTTP/1.1 > User-Agent: curl/7.19.7 (x86_64-pc-linux-gnu) libcurl/7.19.7 OpenSSL/0.9.8k zlib/1.2.3.3 libidn/1.15 > Host: 127.0.0.1:7379 > Accept: */* > Content-Length: 16744 > Expect: 100-continue > < HTTP/1.1 100 Continue < HTTP/1.1 200 OK < Content-Type: application/json < ETag: "0db1124cf79ffeb80aff6d199d5822f8" < Date: Sun, 09 Jan 2011 16:48:19 GMT < Content-Length: 19 < {"SET":[true,"OK"]} $ curl -vs http://127.0.0.1:7379/GET/logo.png -o out.png > GET /GET/logo.png HTTP/1.1 > User-Agent: curl/7.19.7 (x86_64-pc-linux-gnu) libcurl/7.19.7 OpenSSL/0.9.8k zlib/1.2.3.3 libidn/1.15 > Host: 127.0.0.1:7379 > Accept: */* > < HTTP/1.1 200 OK < Content-Type: image/png < ETag: "1991df597267d70bf9066a7d11969da0" < Date: Sun, 09 Jan 2011 16:50:51 GMT < Content-Length: 16744 $ md5sum redis-logo.png out.png 1991df597267d70bf9066a7d11969da0 redis-logo.png 1991df597267d70bf9066a7d11969da0 out.png ``` The file was uploaded and re-downloaded properly: it has the same hash and the content-type was set properly thanks to the `.png` extension. # WebSockets Webdis supports WebSocket clients implementing [RFC 6455](https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc6455). **Important:** WebSocket support is currently _disabled by default_. To enable WebSocket support, set the key named `"websockets"` to value `true` in `webdis.json`, e.g. ```json { "daemonize": false, "websockets": true, } ``` (start and end of file omitted). WebSockets are supported with the following formats, selected by the connection URL: * JSON (on `/` or `/.json`) * Raw Redis wire protocol (on `/.raw`) **Example**: ```javascript function testJSON() { var jsonSocket = new WebSocket("ws://127.0.0.1:7379/.json"); jsonSocket.onmessage = function(messageEvent) { console.log("JSON received:", messageEvent.data); }; jsonSocket.onopen = function() { console.log("JSON socket connected!"); jsonSocket.send(JSON.stringify(["SET", "hello", "world"])); jsonSocket.send(JSON.stringify(["GET", "hello"])); }; } testJSON(); ``` This produces the following output: ``` JSON socket connected! JSON received: {"SET":[true,"OK"]} JSON received: {"GET":"world"} ``` ## WebSockets HTML demo The Webdis repository contains a demo web page with JavaScript code that can be used to test WebSocket support. In a terminal, check out Webdis, build it, and configure it with WebSocket support: ```shell $ cd ~/src/webdis $ make $ vim webdis.json # (edit the file to add "websockets": true) $ grep websockets webdis.json "websockets": true, $ ./webdis ``` Then go to the `tests/` directory and open `websocket.html` with a web browser. # Pub/Sub with chunked transfer encoding Webdis exposes Redis PUB/SUB channels to HTTP clients, forwarding messages in the channel as they are published by Redis. This is done using chunked transfer encoding. **Example using XMLHttpRequest**: ```javascript var previous_response_length = 0 xhr = new XMLHttpRequest() xhr.open("GET", "http://127.0.0.1:7379/SUBSCRIBE/hello", true); xhr.onreadystatechange = checkData; xhr.send(null); function checkData() { if(xhr.readyState == 3) { response = xhr.responseText; chunk = response.slice(previous_response_length); previous_response_length = response.length; console.log(chunk); } }; ``` Publish messages to redis to see output similar to the following: ```json {"SUBSCRIBE":["subscribe","hello",1]} {"SUBSCRIBE":["message","hello","some message"]} {"SUBSCRIBE":["message","hello","some other message"]} ```